Weld identification and classification

Introduction

Welding is the only pipeline fabrication process which occurs in the field. Due to the lack of consistency, welds are the most common locations for failures in a pipeline. Even a perfectly executed welding process introduces material heterogeneity, particularly in the heat-affected zone (HAZ) adjacent to the weld. This zone experiences significant thermal and mechanical changes, including grain coarsening, phase transformations, and residual stresses. The HAZ is also particularly susceptible to stress-induced cracking and corrosion.

Additionally, weld defects such as porosity, incomplete fusion, and slag inclusions act as stress concentrators, further increasing the risk of failure at these locations in the pipeline. Detecting these defects is a key objective of pipeline integrity management. While traditional magnetic flux leakage (MFL) devices have made significant strides in the area of weld inspection, they face limitations in handling pipelines with complex geometries.

Remnant magnetometry offers an alternative approach by analyzing the residual magnetic signatures left by welding and other stress-inducing processes. These signatures provide valuable insights into the structural integrity of pipeline welds, enabling the identification of potential defects.

Weld identification

Weld morphology, as detected by residual magnetometry, is highly varied. Some pipeline welds can be found with a simple peak search, while others appear as subtle increases in oscillation frequency. Others are so subtle that they can only be determined by considering the average weld spacing in the surrounding area.

As weld identification lacks precise articulatable attributes which might lend it to imperative programming, a neural network is the most promising solution.

INGU Weld Net – the INGU Weld identification neural network – is an implementation of U-Net, a widely used deep learning architecture that was first introduced in the “U-Net: Convolutional Networks for Biomedical Image Segmentation” paper . We used a training set of 110,000 samples to train the INGU Weld Net which resulted in 95% automated weld recognition. A task that would typically take days is now performed in less than 1 hour.

The results of this work were first presented at the 2023 Pipeline Technology Conference in Berlin, see our paper Pipeline joint identification using neural networks.

Weld classification

The magnetic signatures of welds in a given pipeline will have some generic weld properties and some pipeline specific properties. Using principal component analysis (PCA) – a statistical method that transforms high-dimensional data into a lower-dimensional space while preserving as much variance as possible –welds in a pipeline can be classified and anomalous welds in the pipeline can be identified.

The essence of the method is that several core shapes (eigenwelds) in a weld are identified and for every weld in a pipeline it is determined which linear combination of these eigenwelds describes the weld best. Consequently, welds that cannot be described with the most dominant eigenwelds are anomalous and worth investigating.

More details about this method can be found in our paper Anomalous Weld Identification by Applying Principal Component Analysis to Magnetic Flux Density Data Captured by a Free-Floating ILI Tool.

Client case study

One of our client’s oil fields had a very old pipeline infrastructure consisting of two- and three-inch pipelines. When the infrastructure was created, none of the conventional inline inspection tools we are familiar with today had the ability to inspect these small pipelines, and therefore our client’s pipelines had never been inspected. When our client had a failure with a pipeline in the area, they started looking for a solution to proactively inspect the pipelines in this field. The client chose to use Pipers® as their pipeline condition assessment solution.

Pipers® inspection results

A typical weld signal is a narrow peak in the magnetic flux density data as highlighted green in below figure. The area highlighted in red was also identified as a weld, but the structure contains multiple peaks and is broader, so it was reported as an anomalous weld. The client did a verification dig and found the weld as shown in the picture below which is a clear case of incomplete penetration.

Pipers® Magnetic Flux Density data.

Cut out of a weld. Left side: inside of the pipeline. Right side: outside of the pipeline.

John Hanten

Operating Partner at Energy Innovation Capital
John is a former Venture Executive from Chevron Technology Ventures. He was responsible for identifying and executing venture capital investments in companies that have technology beneficial to Chevron, and assisting in the introduction and deployment of the technology. John has over 35 years of O&G industry experience. He is currently a Rice Alliance Advisory Board member, and is active in HTC Energy events. John has a BS in Earth Sciences from the University of Minnesota Duluth, a MS in Geophysics from Purdue University (Phi Kappa Phi) and an MBA from St. Mary’s College.

Lynsey Vinikoff

Venture Executive at Chevron Technology Ventures

Lynsey is a Venture Executive with Chevron Technology Ventures on the Core Venture Fund investment team. Chevron Technology Ventures (CTV) was launched in 1999 to identify and integrate externally developed technologies and new business solutions with the potential to enhance the way Chevron produces and delivers affordable, reliable, and ever-cleaner energy now and into the future. Its Core Venture Fund invests in technologies that have the potential to add efficiencies to Chevron’s core business in the areas of operational enhancement, digitalization, and lower-carbon operations.

Lynsey holds a Bachelor of Business Administration in Finance from Texas A&M University in College Station, TX.

Amy Shank

Vice President Safety & Operational Discipline at Williams
Amy is the Vice President of the Safety & Operational Discipline organization for the Williams Company. Her current responsibilities span multiple facets of regulatory compliance, employee & process safety, emergency preparedness & response, maintenance management & GIS system support, asset integrity, incident investigation, and risk. Amy has been with Williams for 25 years and has a total of 34 years of experience in the energy industry overseeing compliance programs, developing and building large scale pipeline and facilities projects, and leading teams of technical experts. Amy has a BS in Mechanical Engineering from the University of Oklahoma and an MBA from Oklahoma City University.

Steve Bolze

Former CEO, GE Power and Water

Steve Bolze recently launched Standish Spring Investments to support founders scaling early and growth stage organizations that support the energy transition.

Prior to launching Standish Spring Investments, Steve was a senior managing director and head of infrastructure portfolio operations and asset management for Blackstone’s dedicated infrastructure business. He was one of the founding partners of Blackstone’s infrastructure investment fund, valued at more than $25 billion currently, and partnered with portfolio company CEOs to drive key value creation initiatives.

Before joining Blackstone, Steve had a nearly 25-year career at General Electric, during which time he successfully led several of the company’s largest businesses. In his last role as President and CEO of GE Power and Water, he oversaw the company’s $28 billion power generation and renewables business, operating in over 140 countries with 52,000 employees; at the time its technology helped provide more than one-quarter of the world’s electricity.

Stay in the loop

Mark Menke

Former General Manager M&A, Chevron
Mark joins INGU’s board of directors after 35 years’ experience in the oil and gas industry. Menke is the former General Manager, Mergers and Acquisitions at Chevron, a position he held for 13 years. During that time, he was also on the advisory board of Chevron Technology Ventures—a role that afforded him unique insights into innovative start-up and growth companies in the energy sector. Mark also served as Global Business Manager for Chevron’s $1B global fuel and lubricant additives division and held the position of Director of Chevron’s International Business Development efforts for 6 years. He currently serves on Rice University’s Engineering Advisory Board and is an independent director with WildFire Energy LLC. Mark brings global oil and gas expertise to INGU’s growing international presence across the industry.

George Coyle

Managing Partner,
Energy Innovation Capital

George is co-founder and managing partner of Energy Innovation Capital, a capital provider to energy innovators. George is an experienced venture capital investor, having co-founded three corporate venture capital groups: Chevron Technology Ventures, ConocoPhillips Technology Ventures Investments and Energy Technology Ventures. He previously worked in Exploration & Production leadership roles at Chevron and is an active member of AAPG, SEG, and SPE. George holds an MBA from Tulane University, a M.S. in Geology from the University of Kansas and a B.S. in Earth Sciences from the University of New Orleans.

Michael Riedijk

Cleantech investor and serial entrepreneur
Experienced CEO and serial entrepreneur with 2 successful tech exits, green/clean tech investor with a history of working on internet, cleantech, agriculture, and marine technology. Strong business development professional with a Master’s Degree in Industrial Design Engineering from Delft University of Technology. Michael’s companies have been awarded the ‘Obama Champion of Change’ Award at The White House in 2011, the ‘Red Herring Top 100 North America 2012’, the ‘Deloitte Technology Fast 500’ for several years in a row, INC 5000 and Growth 500.

John van Pol

CEO and Director, INGU
Innovator and Entrepreneur with a 20+ year career in science and technology with a passion for new and unprecedented ideas. Started working on advanced sensing technologies during his PhD in Nuclear Physics and is currently applying his sensing and data analytics expertise to the oil & gas sector. Brings a superlative career history in leveraging strategic business and institutional partnerships to drive cutting edge research and deliver tangible results to the global marketplace. Offers a comprehensive scientific background reinforced with formidable talent in analyzing, evaluating, and overcoming complex technological, operational, financial, and legal obstacles. Possesses a solid network of business partnerships in the Netherlands and Canada, with an award-winning track record in leading international business development in the European and Canadian markets for advanced sensor application solutions.